I'd been thinking for some time that there are certain moments in fantasy novels that ring in my mind like the call of bells, clear and full of portent. They fill me with emotion and with remembrance.
So this is not a review. Just reproduced for you, a section from David Eddings, Queen of Sorcer, the second book of the Belgariad.
SPOILER ALERT: Not for nothing, cathartic moments in fantasy are "reveals" if you haven't read the book, you might give pause before reading ahead. On the other hand, if this makes you buy the book and read it, then I'll have done my non-job.
Some things you'll need to know. Garion is a foundling child, maybe thirteen or fourteen at this point. Good natured and kind, with a powerful parentage of which he is only just learning. He was raised by his Aunt Pol on a farm, and lived in peace for years before his entire world was uprooted.
-------
"You are who you are, I'll show you. Look! " Unbidden and so clearly that it was almost as if he were watching it happen, the image of the God Torak writhing in th fire of Aldur's Orb rose before his eyes. He saw Torak's face melting and his fingers aflame. Then the face shifted and altered until it was the face of the dark watcher whose mind had been linked with his for as long as he could remember. He felt a terrible force building in him as the image of Chamdar wrapped in seething flame stood before him.
"Now! " the voice commanded him. "Do it! "
It required a blow. His rage would be satisfied with nothing less. He leaped at the smirking Grolim so quickly that none of the legionnaires could stop him. He swung his right arm, and at the instant his palm sturck Chamdar's scarred left cheek, he felt all the force that had built in him surge out from the silvery mark on his palm. "Burn!" he commanded, willing it to happen.
Taken off guard, Chamdar jerked back. A momentary anger began to appear on his face, and then his eyes widened with an awful realization. For an instant he stared at Garion in absolute horror, and then his face contorted with agony. "No!" he cried out hoarsely, and then his cheek began to smoke and seethe where the mark on Garion's hand had touched it. Wisps of smoke drifted from his black robe as if it had suddenly been laid on a red-hot stove. Then he shrieked and clutched at his face. His fingers burst into flame. He shrieked again and fell writhing to the damp earth.
"Stand still! " It was Aunt Pol's voice this time, sounding sharply inside Garion's head.
Chamdar's entire face was engulfed in flames now, and his shrieks echoed in the dim word. The legionnaires recoiled from the burning man, and Garion suddenly felt sick. He started to turn away.
"Don't weaken!" Aunt Pol's voice told him. "Keep your will on him!'
Garion stood over the blazing Grolim. The wet leaves on the ground smoked and smoldered where Chamdar thrashed and struggled with the fire that was consuming him. Flames were spurting from his chest, and his shrieks grew weaker. With an enormous effort, he struggled to his feet and helt out his flaming hands imploringly to Garion. His face was gone, and greasy black smoke rolled off his body, drifting low to the ground. "Master," he croaked, "have mercy!"
Garion's heart wrenched with pity. All the years of that secret closeness between them pulled at him.
"No! " Aunt Pol's stern voice commanded. "He'll kill you if you release him! "
"I can't do it," Garion said. "I'm going to stop it." As once before, he began to gather his will, feeling it build in him like some vast tide of pity and compassion. He reached toward Chamdar, focusing his thought on healing.
"Garion! " Aunt Pol's voice rang. "It was Chamdar who killed your parents! "
The thought forming his mind roze.
"Chamdar killed Geran and Ildera. He burned them alive--just as he's burning now. Avenge them, Garion! Keep the fire on him! "
All the rage and fury he had carried within him since Wolf had told him of the deaths of his parents flamed in his brain. The fire, which a moment before he had almost extinquished, was suddenly not enough. The hand he had begun to reach out in compassion stiffened. In terrible anger he raised it, palm out. A strange sensation tingled in that palm, and then his own hand burst into flames. There was no pain, not even a feeling of heat, as a bright blue fire burst from the mark on his hand and wreathed up through his fingers. The blue fire became brighter--so bright that he could not even look at it.
Even in the extremity of his mortal agony, Chamdar the Grolim recoiled from that blazing hand. With a hoarse despairing cry he tried to cover his blackened face, staggered back a few steps, and then, like a burning house, he collapsed in upon himself and sank back to earth.
"It is done! " Aunt Pol's voice came again. "They are avenged! " And then her voice rang in the vaults of his mind with a soaring exultation. "Belgarion! " she sang. "My Belgarion! "
Comment: Why? Aunt Pol, the only mother Garion ever knew, was threatened by Chamdar, an evil magician. What Garion does here is awful, no child should have to do it. And that beautiful moment of pity he feels toward the smouldering Chamdar is completely eclipsed when he finds out about the terrible crime Chamdar committed against Aunt Pol and himself.
More than that, he uncovers a part of his heritage, and joins a powerful family of sorcerors. It's a moment of keen self discovery, and a truly great Coming of Age.
Search This Blog
Friday, February 4, 2011
Tuesday, February 1, 2011
The Dwarves by Markus Heitz
Let me start this post with a disclaimer:
Anyone who can finish a novel, and get it published has my utmost respect. And more, they are in at least this one way far superior to me: they've the will to see it through.
Criticisms of this book might also be inappropriate for this reason: The Dwarves is one of those few fantasy novels that bridged the language gap. Every single other fantasy book I've ever read, and I've read many, were in English. Translating from German is hard, and my philosophy professors always assured me, particularly the Germans, that a great deal is lost in even the best translation. One of my central criticisms of this book is that the prose is simple to the point of being for a much younger audience, twelve to thirteen. I suggest that this is the publisher's fault. German is an exceedingly colorful language, and each word is dense with meaning. This was not a book to go Hemmingway on. But Americans are thought by editors at large to be fairly simplistic in their reading level, and so perhaps there is a sensible reason for this fault. Compare the prose of The Dwarves to the prose of Erikson's from The Malazan Book of the Fallen and you'll see what I mean.
Overall, I enjoyed this book. There's enough going for it, that I'd consider reading the sequel. As usual, I'd seen this title in the bookstore and admired its fine cover. Not only that, but I was intrigued. Dwarves are usually in the model of Gimli from LOTR, amusing sidekicks, or Flint from the Dragonlance Saga. The implication, and truth of the title, is that this might be one of the first such fantasy novels where the hero is a dwarf. The book had an interesting, relatively swift moving plot, some gruesome details, and an exciting conclusion.
Very well, let's get to the five.
1. Character: This is perhaps my primary complaint about the story. The characters are very naive. Naivety is only bearable when it proves a point, is a statement about the character, not the writer. Rand Al'Thor starts out the Wheel of Time very naive. But Jordan does this intentionally, to show that he's an eighteen year old boy from a farming village. Every single character, except maybe one, the Maga Andokai are naive to the point of iritation. And they say the lamest things to one another! The main character Tungdil is the worst for this, but even the main vilain, the Nudin the Knowledge-Lusty (For real! Really, a better translation wasn't available? Maybe Google translate did their translation) was exceptionally naive. He ravages his own homeland, convinced that he's acting on the greater good. This would be an interesting character development except that it's not really talked about much, save for one of the the story's modes: the play within the play. And he has a good excuse, he's inhabited by a demon spirit. Madness is intriguing, ethical decision making is intriguing, devil possession is passing the buck. In this case, passing it to the sequel I imagine.
The other reason The Dwarves fell flat, is that the Dwarves themselves were remarkably bland. There is an interesting mythology presented, five clans of dwarves, separated by their God, Vraccas. (*I was dismayed by the name Vraccas, in one of my own unfinished works of 2002, I'd chosen this exact name to be an evil god.) The dwarven mythos is essential to the story, and is one of the most enjoyable elements. But even so, detail regarding the lives of regular dwarves was incredibly sparse. Worse, Heitz had an excellent vehicle for doing so, and since the main character is a foundling, every sentence between two dwarves would have added color. It's like a six year old's coloring book, full of poorly colored shapes, many pages left entirely blank. Worser: There's millions of helpful dwarven cliches in other fantasy novels that could provide further description without dragging down the plot. This is why cliche's are useful, they speak volumes.
2) Let's talk about Cliche: Heitz had two options here. Use the old dwarven cliches laid down by Tolkien, and many since, or bust a nut and create something new. Either would have worked well for me. However, by using a familiar race, beloved of fantasy readers everywhere, Heitz had already consigned himself to a certain amount of necessary cliche. Let's see here: Dwarves are short: check. Dwarves prefer underground mountainous lairs: check. Dwarves hate magic: check. Dwarves are long lived: check. Dwarves prefer axes: check. Dwarves are smiths: check. Dwarves love gold: check. Heitz had a subtle spin on the dwarven love of gold, he made it genetic. By which I mean, Dwarves have the love of gold and gems intrinsically. Men love gold too, but its generally admitted that we love it for the things, including sex and status, that it can get for us. Dwarves just like how it looks, sort of like human women. Heitz also used the dwarven cliche of using names that involve all of the above. I enjoy this particular cliche quite a bit, so no problems here. In fact, these standard fantasy cliche's held true for all of the races. Let's coin a term, "LOTR Race Cliche" shall mean that Dwarves are short and bulbous, Elves are tall and fair, humans are enh, orcs are evil.
The Coming of Age cliche was also used to some degree, though somewhat inexplicalbly. Tungdil is 60 years old when the story starts. This is really only about a third of a dwarf's life. But I'm at a third through my life, and I don't act like a twenty year old, so what's this guy's excuse? Tungdil isn't immature, he's just completely innocent. Naive, as stated above. And it bugged the hell out of me. At 60 years old, you've learned a lot about life, particularly when you've spent the entire time living among humans. That's at least two generations of medieval humans he would have lived through. Still there are some good reasons, he's never met a female of his race. God knows, women give you gray hairs. And he's never met a male of his race, so when he meets the story's comic relief, the warrior twins Boindil and Boendil, acting a bit childlike would be understandable. This leads to a third cliche: Self-Actualization.
Coming of Age cliche's often become self-actualization cliches. In the Eye of the World, Rand al'Thor becomes a man. But through the remainder of the series, he continues to grow and change, leaving behind the Coming of Age cliche of the first book. Tungdil has a problem: he knows nothing about his race, other than what he's read in books. Fortunately for him, everything he ever learned in his books about dwarves was completely accurate. This bothered me, again I felt like this book was aimed at thirteen year olds. That would be fine, but good fantasy is aimed at a much broader audience, thirteen year olds included. I don't need you to tell me that books are good, thank you very much.
3. Scope: The scope of the novel was perfect. The realm is called Girdlegard (again, an awful translation choice--literally, the land is wearing a girdle that guards it from evil.) Still Girdlegard is small, with delineated borders, and the reader is not in any way made curious about what lies beyond those borders. A common fantasy trope is to name off lands far distant without providing a purpose for these lands. Such a trope is merely to show that that the story takes place in a larger land, not in space. Personally, I prefer bounded lands because, well frankly, its easy to make up funny names and toss in a sentence about far away lands. It's a bad writers trick (I know, I use it) Heitz doesn't indulge. That said, there are just too many lands for a fairly simple story. Were six human kingdoms really necessary? No. Only two are relevant. In contrast, the five dwarven realms are completely relevant, and tantalizingly explained. I mentioned in my last post how difficult it is to indicate scope without falling into such tropes, but Heitz sidesteps the issue very nicely.
4. Magic: The story starts out with there being six main Magi, male and female. And they save the realm from another cliche, The Perished Land. Not unlike Jordan's Blight.
Nothing grows in the Perished Land, and anyone who dies in it is forced to walk the land as a revenant, enslaved to the will of some gaseous form of evil that is only hinted at. Magic isn't really explained, and Heitz falls back on more cliches, spell books, runes, jars of ingredients, eye of newt, you know the deal. One thing for sure about magic. You can eat other Magi's magical power. Guess how. It's an important plot point, but Heitz doesn't bother to explain it. And maybe he's right--Dwarves hate magic. And if nothing else, The Dwarves, is about Dwarves. One fairly interesting and enjoyable part of the story is that, much of the book is taken up with quests searching for magical artifacts. This is something fairly rare in fantasy of the past twenty years which is primarily character driven. I don't want to spoil the novel, but it becomes clear in the first fifty pages, that the big bad can't be killed with the usual assortment of weaponry. Magical weapons are cool, and anyone who ever played a fantasy board game, videogame or the beknighted Dungeons and Dragons knows it.
Anyone who can finish a novel, and get it published has my utmost respect. And more, they are in at least this one way far superior to me: they've the will to see it through.
Criticisms of this book might also be inappropriate for this reason: The Dwarves is one of those few fantasy novels that bridged the language gap. Every single other fantasy book I've ever read, and I've read many, were in English. Translating from German is hard, and my philosophy professors always assured me, particularly the Germans, that a great deal is lost in even the best translation. One of my central criticisms of this book is that the prose is simple to the point of being for a much younger audience, twelve to thirteen. I suggest that this is the publisher's fault. German is an exceedingly colorful language, and each word is dense with meaning. This was not a book to go Hemmingway on. But Americans are thought by editors at large to be fairly simplistic in their reading level, and so perhaps there is a sensible reason for this fault. Compare the prose of The Dwarves to the prose of Erikson's from The Malazan Book of the Fallen and you'll see what I mean.
Overall, I enjoyed this book. There's enough going for it, that I'd consider reading the sequel. As usual, I'd seen this title in the bookstore and admired its fine cover. Not only that, but I was intrigued. Dwarves are usually in the model of Gimli from LOTR, amusing sidekicks, or Flint from the Dragonlance Saga. The implication, and truth of the title, is that this might be one of the first such fantasy novels where the hero is a dwarf. The book had an interesting, relatively swift moving plot, some gruesome details, and an exciting conclusion.
Very well, let's get to the five.
1. Character: This is perhaps my primary complaint about the story. The characters are very naive. Naivety is only bearable when it proves a point, is a statement about the character, not the writer. Rand Al'Thor starts out the Wheel of Time very naive. But Jordan does this intentionally, to show that he's an eighteen year old boy from a farming village. Every single character, except maybe one, the Maga Andokai are naive to the point of iritation. And they say the lamest things to one another! The main character Tungdil is the worst for this, but even the main vilain, the Nudin the Knowledge-Lusty (For real! Really, a better translation wasn't available? Maybe Google translate did their translation) was exceptionally naive. He ravages his own homeland, convinced that he's acting on the greater good. This would be an interesting character development except that it's not really talked about much, save for one of the the story's modes: the play within the play. And he has a good excuse, he's inhabited by a demon spirit. Madness is intriguing, ethical decision making is intriguing, devil possession is passing the buck. In this case, passing it to the sequel I imagine.
The other reason The Dwarves fell flat, is that the Dwarves themselves were remarkably bland. There is an interesting mythology presented, five clans of dwarves, separated by their God, Vraccas. (*I was dismayed by the name Vraccas, in one of my own unfinished works of 2002, I'd chosen this exact name to be an evil god.) The dwarven mythos is essential to the story, and is one of the most enjoyable elements. But even so, detail regarding the lives of regular dwarves was incredibly sparse. Worse, Heitz had an excellent vehicle for doing so, and since the main character is a foundling, every sentence between two dwarves would have added color. It's like a six year old's coloring book, full of poorly colored shapes, many pages left entirely blank. Worser: There's millions of helpful dwarven cliches in other fantasy novels that could provide further description without dragging down the plot. This is why cliche's are useful, they speak volumes.
2) Let's talk about Cliche: Heitz had two options here. Use the old dwarven cliches laid down by Tolkien, and many since, or bust a nut and create something new. Either would have worked well for me. However, by using a familiar race, beloved of fantasy readers everywhere, Heitz had already consigned himself to a certain amount of necessary cliche. Let's see here: Dwarves are short: check. Dwarves prefer underground mountainous lairs: check. Dwarves hate magic: check. Dwarves are long lived: check. Dwarves prefer axes: check. Dwarves are smiths: check. Dwarves love gold: check. Heitz had a subtle spin on the dwarven love of gold, he made it genetic. By which I mean, Dwarves have the love of gold and gems intrinsically. Men love gold too, but its generally admitted that we love it for the things, including sex and status, that it can get for us. Dwarves just like how it looks, sort of like human women. Heitz also used the dwarven cliche of using names that involve all of the above. I enjoy this particular cliche quite a bit, so no problems here. In fact, these standard fantasy cliche's held true for all of the races. Let's coin a term, "LOTR Race Cliche" shall mean that Dwarves are short and bulbous, Elves are tall and fair, humans are enh, orcs are evil.
The Coming of Age cliche was also used to some degree, though somewhat inexplicalbly. Tungdil is 60 years old when the story starts. This is really only about a third of a dwarf's life. But I'm at a third through my life, and I don't act like a twenty year old, so what's this guy's excuse? Tungdil isn't immature, he's just completely innocent. Naive, as stated above. And it bugged the hell out of me. At 60 years old, you've learned a lot about life, particularly when you've spent the entire time living among humans. That's at least two generations of medieval humans he would have lived through. Still there are some good reasons, he's never met a female of his race. God knows, women give you gray hairs. And he's never met a male of his race, so when he meets the story's comic relief, the warrior twins Boindil and Boendil, acting a bit childlike would be understandable. This leads to a third cliche: Self-Actualization.
Coming of Age cliche's often become self-actualization cliches. In the Eye of the World, Rand al'Thor becomes a man. But through the remainder of the series, he continues to grow and change, leaving behind the Coming of Age cliche of the first book. Tungdil has a problem: he knows nothing about his race, other than what he's read in books. Fortunately for him, everything he ever learned in his books about dwarves was completely accurate. This bothered me, again I felt like this book was aimed at thirteen year olds. That would be fine, but good fantasy is aimed at a much broader audience, thirteen year olds included. I don't need you to tell me that books are good, thank you very much.
3. Scope: The scope of the novel was perfect. The realm is called Girdlegard (again, an awful translation choice--literally, the land is wearing a girdle that guards it from evil.) Still Girdlegard is small, with delineated borders, and the reader is not in any way made curious about what lies beyond those borders. A common fantasy trope is to name off lands far distant without providing a purpose for these lands. Such a trope is merely to show that that the story takes place in a larger land, not in space. Personally, I prefer bounded lands because, well frankly, its easy to make up funny names and toss in a sentence about far away lands. It's a bad writers trick (I know, I use it) Heitz doesn't indulge. That said, there are just too many lands for a fairly simple story. Were six human kingdoms really necessary? No. Only two are relevant. In contrast, the five dwarven realms are completely relevant, and tantalizingly explained. I mentioned in my last post how difficult it is to indicate scope without falling into such tropes, but Heitz sidesteps the issue very nicely.
5. Theme: It's hard to get a handle on the overall theme of The Dwarves. It might be too basic. If the prose were more detailed, or better translated, I could make a better stab. The Perished Land isn't particularly dark or frightening, and the revenants can talk, and in some cases, even be completely normal. So darkness as a theme is out. I guess if I had to peg it, I'd say, unity. There's a weird scene in the end, after the big bad is beat, where a minor character makes a speech about unity between the races. Given the happy-go-lucky nature of the characters, this theme seems to be the most prevalent. I can't complain, go Unity. Go Peace. But...again, I'm not thirteen.
If the cover weren't so groovy, I'd tell you to borrow a copy. Want mine?
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
Brent Weeks - The Night Angel Trilogy
Sorry for the long silence my fine friends. I've been busy at work, grad school, and other blogging projects. This post is about only two of Brent Week's books in the Night Angel Trilogy: The Way of Shadows
, and Shadow's Edge
. Nearly finished with the second, I can say that I am definitely intrigued enough to finish the series. Still, I have some hang-ups with the story, the main character, and the style. But the ending of both books is exciting with some novel surprises which make the series a worthwhile read, if not a shelf stuffer. A shelf stuffer, I define, is a book worth keeping to reread.
On to the Five Factors
1) Character. There are some great and memorable characters in both books, however they suffer, in my opinion from some structural flaws. As you may have guessed from the titles of the books, which say very little about the books individually and really only make for good book jackets, this is a series about assassins. Assassins are romantic favorites for many young fantasists. They're dark, ruthless, and mysterious, and these things can make them appear sexy. In popular fiction, assassins are good fodder for paperback drivel, think Jason Bourne
and such. Or historical works like the assassins in Munich would also be a good example. Femme Fatales are famously sexy assassins, beautiful, broken, dead dolls who are either totally despicable, or have hearts of gold buried deep in their lithe sexy bodies. Week's works take a more fantasy approach of the genre, with bladework and poisions, traps and such. But our main character, Kylar Stern, is no typical assassin. He's neither ruthless, nor for much of the novels, is he a particularly effective killer, botching many of the jobs he's sent on. In short, he's a highly likeable assassin. However, there's a disconnect, because his repute in the book, is the repute of a cold hearted killer, feared by many. Though he kills, and is extremely well trained, Brent fails to convince me that this character is actually an assassin. Far more interesting of course, is his mentor, Durzo Blint (Week's names for his two main protagonists are terrible. Durzo Blint, sounds like a Polish pastry.) but more of this troph later. Another failing of Weeks in this novel is that new characters who will actually make a difference in the plot are introduced two or three hundred pages into the novel. While this technique is used in other more successful pieces of fantasy, Weeks introduction of these characters is arbitrary and unnecessary. Characters like Dorian, Solon, and Feir are barely explained, fulfil several nearly inscrutable purposes in the plot and then disappear until they are next needed to grease the wheels of narrative fiction.
2) Cliche. I've already touched on the main cliche, use of an Assassin as a main character. There have been some great fantasy assassins on my shelves. Hugh the Hand is an old favorite, from Margaret Weiss and Tracy Hickman's Deathgate Cycle, a truly phenomonal series. The assassin cliche is this: Embittered embodiment of death, ninja-like stealth, a vast array of dainty killing instruments, Ruthless Assassin ("RA") whose soul has been so destroyed by his evil work, killing innocents/killing in coldblood, loneliness and disconnection, finally meets the gig he can't deliver on and finds that he is afterall a human being. In The Way of Shadows, the RAs deviate from this model in that they have friends, loves, even children. Moreover, a lot of their jobs are won through blunt force. One man against twenty palace guards, fighting with British long swords in open passageways. Stealth is only occasionally applied, and is even more rarely successful. Steven Erikson does a better job with his assassin, Kalaam in the Malazan Book of the Fallen series. Kalaam, is a cold hearted killer, who is at the same time imensely intriguing and a hero of the series. There is never a question about his tempermant, where Durzo Blint is prone to massive episodes of excessive drinking and disorderly conduct. Disorderly assassins are dead assassins. But not in the Night Angel Trilogy. Robin Hobb
made a similar mistake in the Assassin's Apprentice
, in which the main character never really gets mean enough to be believed.
Look, I don't have a problem with deviations from the cliche, but this rational divide is never adequately explained. Coldblooded killers can't have regular lives. If they did, they'd be constantly asking themselves the questions that would surely undermine their work. To be sure, Kylar and Durzo have a host of emotional issues, but neither of them are cold blooded enough to be entirelely believable as assassins. Perhaps this was Week's intention, modern fantasists attempt to break through cliches rather than use them. But in this case, the attempt was not executed well. Only two of the stories assassins, both minor characters, really fit with the cliche, and both are evil, blood thirsty menaces.
The second cliche, which is executed fairly well, is a Coming of Age cliche. Before becoming an assassin, Kylar is a gutter boy named Azoth, who joins the netherworld to protect his two friends, one of whom becomes his girlfriend in later years from a local tyrant. He becomes apprenticed to Durzo Blint, and learns the trade from the older killer. This section of the book is about fifty pages too long, and doesn't really move the plot along all that much. Moreover, it makes Kylar even more likeable. Even so, Kylar's likeability and struggle with his impoverished background makes him a character worthy of following, and provides the story with a basic thematic outline. I think this might be why Weeks and Hobb failed where Erikson and Weiss succeeded, Erikson and Weiss came into the story in the middle of their assassin's lives. You never saw the foibles and trips along the way to deadliness for Hugh the Hand or Kalaam.
They started the series unrepentant monsters and were redeemed through valorous, selfless acts. Weeks and Hobb's characters are flawed humans forced to an ugly trade, who are indeed redeemed, but never really damned.
3) Scope: Few novels pack the scope of The Wheel of Time
. I should get used to that. In my own half-hearted attempts at fiction I can recognize the same problem in my work, but its difficult to get the mind around. You have to hint at the world beyond, you have to hint at ages of history, but you can't bludgeon your audience with it, and you can't waste time describing it when you should be illustrating it. LOTR and Wheel of Time do this primarily through the use of ancient ruins and old sages. But honestly, its something I struggle with and I can't provide much guidance for authors.
There are at least three, four nations in The Night Angel Trilogy, though the action in the first book takes place almost entirely in one city. They are "modern nations" in that little history of the warring nations is discussed save for the most recent. The encroaching empire of the evil GodKing, is one nation, and is pivotal to the story. To be sure, The Night Angel series has a myth structure, centered around one character who I can't name without spoiling the first book. There's a wide world out there in Week's Night Angel, but its still sketchy. I can only describe it with the use of a poor metaphor. Worlds like these are like reading about other countries in a newspaper, vague and impersonal unless you know a lot about them already. World's like the Wheel of Time, are like holding up a lantern in a darkened room. Everything out there is hinted at by vague shapes in the darkness, and yet, has a reality which is undeniable and fascinating. Hobb's world was similar to the Night Angel's save that her second series The Liveship Traders
started out entirely different characters in the same world, granting authority to some of the places on the map in the first series. Judging by Weeks' prolific nature, I assume that many of these lands will be defined in later works. But it's an awful risk to assume that I'm interested enough to keep going.
4) Magic. Week's system of magic is poorly defined. But it doesn't really detract from the action. For most of the characters, magic is used as assassins would use it, for stealth, crawling up walls, disappearing, charming, etc. There are brief descriptions. It's rechargable by sunlight in most cases, and it's also called Vir. And magic users who are "Talented" usually join various schools of magic which irrevocably shape the direction of their skills. The GodKing and his minions have it in spades, and his Vurdmeisters are formidable killers. There seems to be an endless supply of mages in both books for Kylar to kill. And then of course, there are magic swords, and magical stones, which are the source of The Night Angel's power. However, Weeks does an excellent job of creating horrors like the Ferrali in Shadow's Edge. I won't bother to describe, it's pretty gross, and you should read it and find out. Click on the amazon associates logos above and I'll get cents for your efforts! These things require magic to function, and even if the technique is never explained, the images Weeks creates are worth discovering on your own.
5) Theme. This is a fantasy for city boys and girls. All of the action takes place in busy cities which are ruled by a criminal underworld which is known to be cruel, and yet is at the same time benevolent (don't get me started on that contradiction). The settings are rooftops and ceilings, corridors and passage ways. If this series has a theme at all, it's a sort of proletariat pick yourself up by the bootstraps and kick ass feel. Even so, it's a fairly cosmopolitan tale involving child abuse, both sexual and physical, holy rollers, insane killers ignorant nobles, and the types of poverty that are more common in early industrial cities, not preindustrial societies like the Night Angel world. Kylar's struggle to be a good human being, to find love and happiness, to grow up and "be a mensch" fit with the above mentioned cliche, and provide a cluttered story a stable protaganist to follow.
On the whole, these books are worth a read. Borrow them if you can, but if not they're in paper back and the whole series is fairly cheap. Or go E-book, the cover art is pretty lame so you won't be missing much. None of the weaponry wielded by the photographed model on the cover are used by Kylar or Durzo, who predominantly kill with sword and daggers, so you definitely can't go by my earlier suggestion of buying based on the cover.
Note to Publishers: Avoid trilogies. I never get through them anymore. Go big or go home.
On to the Five Factors
1) Character. There are some great and memorable characters in both books, however they suffer, in my opinion from some structural flaws. As you may have guessed from the titles of the books, which say very little about the books individually and really only make for good book jackets, this is a series about assassins. Assassins are romantic favorites for many young fantasists. They're dark, ruthless, and mysterious, and these things can make them appear sexy. In popular fiction, assassins are good fodder for paperback drivel, think Jason Bourne
2) Cliche. I've already touched on the main cliche, use of an Assassin as a main character. There have been some great fantasy assassins on my shelves. Hugh the Hand is an old favorite, from Margaret Weiss and Tracy Hickman's Deathgate Cycle, a truly phenomonal series. The assassin cliche is this: Embittered embodiment of death, ninja-like stealth, a vast array of dainty killing instruments, Ruthless Assassin ("RA") whose soul has been so destroyed by his evil work, killing innocents/killing in coldblood, loneliness and disconnection, finally meets the gig he can't deliver on and finds that he is afterall a human being. In The Way of Shadows, the RAs deviate from this model in that they have friends, loves, even children. Moreover, a lot of their jobs are won through blunt force. One man against twenty palace guards, fighting with British long swords in open passageways. Stealth is only occasionally applied, and is even more rarely successful. Steven Erikson does a better job with his assassin, Kalaam in the Malazan Book of the Fallen series. Kalaam, is a cold hearted killer, who is at the same time imensely intriguing and a hero of the series. There is never a question about his tempermant, where Durzo Blint is prone to massive episodes of excessive drinking and disorderly conduct. Disorderly assassins are dead assassins. But not in the Night Angel Trilogy. Robin Hobb
Look, I don't have a problem with deviations from the cliche, but this rational divide is never adequately explained. Coldblooded killers can't have regular lives. If they did, they'd be constantly asking themselves the questions that would surely undermine their work. To be sure, Kylar and Durzo have a host of emotional issues, but neither of them are cold blooded enough to be entirelely believable as assassins. Perhaps this was Week's intention, modern fantasists attempt to break through cliches rather than use them. But in this case, the attempt was not executed well. Only two of the stories assassins, both minor characters, really fit with the cliche, and both are evil, blood thirsty menaces.
A third cliche, begun in the second book, The Shadow's Edge, is the concept of a sisterhood of magic users, very much like Jordan's Aes Sedai or Goodkind's
Sisters of the Dark. There's not much substance to it, so I won't waste your time.
3) Scope: Few novels pack the scope of The Wheel of Time
There are at least three, four nations in The Night Angel Trilogy, though the action in the first book takes place almost entirely in one city. They are "modern nations" in that little history of the warring nations is discussed save for the most recent. The encroaching empire of the evil GodKing, is one nation, and is pivotal to the story. To be sure, The Night Angel series has a myth structure, centered around one character who I can't name without spoiling the first book. There's a wide world out there in Week's Night Angel, but its still sketchy. I can only describe it with the use of a poor metaphor. Worlds like these are like reading about other countries in a newspaper, vague and impersonal unless you know a lot about them already. World's like the Wheel of Time, are like holding up a lantern in a darkened room. Everything out there is hinted at by vague shapes in the darkness, and yet, has a reality which is undeniable and fascinating. Hobb's world was similar to the Night Angel's save that her second series The Liveship Traders
4) Magic. Week's system of magic is poorly defined. But it doesn't really detract from the action. For most of the characters, magic is used as assassins would use it, for stealth, crawling up walls, disappearing, charming, etc. There are brief descriptions. It's rechargable by sunlight in most cases, and it's also called Vir. And magic users who are "Talented" usually join various schools of magic which irrevocably shape the direction of their skills. The GodKing and his minions have it in spades, and his Vurdmeisters are formidable killers. There seems to be an endless supply of mages in both books for Kylar to kill. And then of course, there are magic swords, and magical stones, which are the source of The Night Angel's power. However, Weeks does an excellent job of creating horrors like the Ferrali in Shadow's Edge. I won't bother to describe, it's pretty gross, and you should read it and find out. Click on the amazon associates logos above and I'll get cents for your efforts! These things require magic to function, and even if the technique is never explained, the images Weeks creates are worth discovering on your own.
5) Theme. This is a fantasy for city boys and girls. All of the action takes place in busy cities which are ruled by a criminal underworld which is known to be cruel, and yet is at the same time benevolent (don't get me started on that contradiction). The settings are rooftops and ceilings, corridors and passage ways. If this series has a theme at all, it's a sort of proletariat pick yourself up by the bootstraps and kick ass feel. Even so, it's a fairly cosmopolitan tale involving child abuse, both sexual and physical, holy rollers, insane killers ignorant nobles, and the types of poverty that are more common in early industrial cities, not preindustrial societies like the Night Angel world. Kylar's struggle to be a good human being, to find love and happiness, to grow up and "be a mensch" fit with the above mentioned cliche, and provide a cluttered story a stable protaganist to follow.
On the whole, these books are worth a read. Borrow them if you can, but if not they're in paper back and the whole series is fairly cheap. Or go E-book, the cover art is pretty lame so you won't be missing much. None of the weaponry wielded by the photographed model on the cover are used by Kylar or Durzo, who predominantly kill with sword and daggers, so you definitely can't go by my earlier suggestion of buying based on the cover.
Note to Publishers: Avoid trilogies. I never get through them anymore. Go big or go home.
Friday, September 3, 2010
The Great eReader Debate
So the New York Times published a lengthy examination over the debate about the future of books. As this is a book blog, I felt I should weigh in. Kindles

, iPads
, iPhones
, and their competition abound. The article in The New York Times, did not however mention the most critical problems with eReading that I have.
Instead, the hype was about how the wife liked the look and feel of the paperback, the husband liked the sleek design and functionality of the iPad and thought only the content mattered. What a ludicrous argument.
I'm going to write this post Wittgenstein style.
1. iPads
are expensive.
2. Kindles
are expensive.
3. Storage space
is expensive.
4. Paper back books are cheap.
If the publishing industry dies, maybe they won't be cheap anymore, but at this point, it's still much cheaper for me to buy a paperback. Which leads me to another point.
5. eBooks are only available for "subway fiction
," those of us who prefer niche fiction
, or non-fiction that's not book of the month, are still getting the shaft.
6. I don't care about the look and feel of the paperback.
7. I lose shit.
8. I've lost three phones in two years. I lost my phone two months ago and a kind soul returned it.
9. I've been damn lucky with my iPod
. I've only lost that three times and managed to get it back all three times, once after it spent the night outdoors.
10. If I lose my eReader, I'm up shits creek. Unless they offer eReader insurance
. Either way, my enjoyment of a novel is circumvented until the damn thing can be replaced.
11. I don't have time to read.
12. I'd much prefer e-audiobooks
.
13. I have the kind of job where an audiobook would be very helpful.
14. Millions of people in this world have similar jobs where they need their fingers eyes and hands, but not necessarily their brains.
15. Audio books are only available for "subway fiction
"
16. Tor released Brandon Sanderson's new book, The Way of Kings. The hardcover is $30, the ebook is $14. The audiobook is $70. I'll wait a year and buy the paperback for $10.
17. My wife would love for me to get rid of my fantasy books. An eReader would be a great way to accomplish that.
18. I'll miss the pretty fantasy covers
. iPads could include more illustrations, cheaply. Yay pretty fantasy covers. Yay interactive comic books
19. What if the power goes?
20. What if the power stays gone?
21. I live in a city where the power almost never goes off, but has on two notable occasions.
22. It was nice to have a paperback at the time.
23. It was more nice to drink the beer before it skunked because of the heat.
24. What about upgrades and new equipment costs?
25. I've read Eye of the World 15 times. I've never had to replace it.
26. My Great Hunt was not so fortunate. I've replaced that twice at a cost of under $20.
27. Technology gets stolen.
28. No one steals books.
29. I mean, maybe the dead sea scrolls
. Or buy the ebook
30. The market for books has dwindled.
31. Ordinary people don't read books anymore, they watch TV, see movies, play videogames.
32. The problem isn't paper backs, the problem is that books are now luxury, elite goods. And only the elite can afford these technologies.
33. I forgot another hidden cost. You need a computer to buy an eBook.
34. You need a computer to store eBooks.
35. Even if eReaders come equipped with wireless and can buy their own content, you're still faced with the same basic problems. How many books can your eReader store? What if you lose your eReader? Does that mean you lose $60-200 worth of books stored on it?
I'm not opposed to eReading. I'm opposed to the burden of cost it places on a reader. Most of the "readers" of the world work in publishing these days. That makes them a bit myopic because many of their companies provide eReaders to their staffs as a matter of course. I do not anticipate buying an eReader in the next year. I spend $400 dollars on books every year. Lucky for me, if the publishing industry dies, my paperbacks will survive at least another twenty years, and I can re-read them as many times as I like.
Unless my fiance throws them out.
Instead, the hype was about how the wife liked the look and feel of the paperback, the husband liked the sleek design and functionality of the iPad and thought only the content mattered. What a ludicrous argument.
I'm going to write this post Wittgenstein style.
1. iPads
2. Kindles
3. Storage space
4. Paper back books are cheap.
If the publishing industry dies, maybe they won't be cheap anymore, but at this point, it's still much cheaper for me to buy a paperback. Which leads me to another point.
5. eBooks are only available for "subway fiction
6. I don't care about the look and feel of the paperback.
7. I lose shit.
8. I've lost three phones in two years. I lost my phone two months ago and a kind soul returned it.
9. I've been damn lucky with my iPod
10. If I lose my eReader, I'm up shits creek. Unless they offer eReader insurance
11. I don't have time to read.
12. I'd much prefer e-audiobooks
13. I have the kind of job where an audiobook would be very helpful.
14. Millions of people in this world have similar jobs where they need their fingers eyes and hands, but not necessarily their brains.
15. Audio books are only available for "subway fiction
16. Tor released Brandon Sanderson's new book, The Way of Kings. The hardcover is $30, the ebook is $14. The audiobook is $70. I'll wait a year and buy the paperback for $10.
17. My wife would love for me to get rid of my fantasy books. An eReader would be a great way to accomplish that.
18. I'll miss the pretty fantasy covers
19. What if the power goes?
20. What if the power stays gone?
21. I live in a city where the power almost never goes off, but has on two notable occasions.
22. It was nice to have a paperback at the time.
23. It was more nice to drink the beer before it skunked because of the heat.
24. What about upgrades and new equipment costs?
25. I've read Eye of the World 15 times. I've never had to replace it.
26. My Great Hunt was not so fortunate. I've replaced that twice at a cost of under $20.
27. Technology gets stolen.
28. No one steals books.
29. I mean, maybe the dead sea scrolls
30. The market for books has dwindled.
31. Ordinary people don't read books anymore, they watch TV, see movies, play videogames.
32. The problem isn't paper backs, the problem is that books are now luxury, elite goods. And only the elite can afford these technologies.
33. I forgot another hidden cost. You need a computer to buy an eBook.
34. You need a computer to store eBooks.
35. Even if eReaders come equipped with wireless and can buy their own content, you're still faced with the same basic problems. How many books can your eReader store? What if you lose your eReader? Does that mean you lose $60-200 worth of books stored on it?
I'm not opposed to eReading. I'm opposed to the burden of cost it places on a reader. Most of the "readers" of the world work in publishing these days. That makes them a bit myopic because many of their companies provide eReaders to their staffs as a matter of course. I do not anticipate buying an eReader in the next year. I spend $400 dollars on books every year. Lucky for me, if the publishing industry dies, my paperbacks will survive at least another twenty years, and I can re-read them as many times as I like.
Unless my fiance throws them out.
Tuesday, August 31, 2010
Videogame: DragonAge: Origins
So, I'm going to expand this blog to include fantasy video games because I found a crunkin' awesome one. This game will knock your socks off.
I was waitng for the next big fantasy game to come along. I'm sort of retro in my video gaming. This is because of a general technological lag in equipment, and the fact that I'm fully employed, in grad school, and engaged to a Ph.D. student. This does not leave much time for video game playing.
So you know where I'm coming from, some of my favorite fantasy and fantasy related video games include Heroes of Might and Magic III
, the entire Final Fantasy franchise from Final Fantasy II
on up., to F
inal Fantasy 12. I also like strategy fantasy games like Age of Empires
and Age of Mythology
. And of course, the entire Baldur's Gate
series.
So on to DragonAge: Origins. When I finished classes this summer, I wanted some innocuous fun during my time off. I checked list after list for the best RPGs. I wanted something current, but I wanted to stay away from online video games. Why? Without diverging too much: time for videogames, is time for me, and me alone. I am NOT looking for any interraction with the broader populace. I have an active social life, I don't need friends online. This is not to disparage people who do--merely expressing a preference. I was exceedingly disappointed when Square released Final Fantasy 11 as only an online game. That's right--you can't actually even play it without going on line. I was very much afraid that DragonAge would be a game like that. The game does in fact have that capability, but it has an undeniable throughline that is completely playable without the internet. What a relief.
I'd also heard that there were some difficulties with the PC version of the game. Employees of both GameStop and BestBuy who raved about the game, both suggested I buy the console version, and stay away from the PC. Had I an XBox or PS3, I may have done so. But I got a new computer just a year ago. I purposely spent twenty bucks extra for a nice video card, and fifty for extra ram, but my machine is by no means a performance whore. I wouldn't even know how to make a gaming machine. As it is, you'll be glad to know the game plays absolutely fine. The Wiki for DragonAge has reported on some general programming bugs, but they have not made the game in anyway unplayable, unlike my attempt at playing the more recent Heroes of Might and Magic, which required seven different patches to play.
So onto the FFF
Note: I haven't finished the game, I was too excited to wait. And I rarely get to finish videogames, which require a skill and tenacity that simple reading does not.
1) Character:
So holy neato! You don't just play one character in DragonAge Origins. When you start, you get to choose one of six different story lines. The quests are largely universal, but the dialogue changes for each character. You can choose from three races, two genders, and the choice of a Magi, creates a wholly different storyline. I chose the story of a Dwarf Commoner. So, I can almost guarantee that many of the developers who worked on Baldur's Gate, also worked on DragonAge. Much of the informational dialogue is written in the same way, and, the controls and view points are very similar. One neat thing about DragonAge, is that you can zoom in on the character and play it first person, from any perspective. I don't particularly like the claustophobic nature of first person shooters, so I tend to operate at the three quarter level, but when I want to see a detail of the scenery, it's nice to be able to zoom in. As in any video game a la Baldur's Gate, or any role playing game, you get to choose the sort of dialogue you want. You can be a buttface, but you can also play really good characters. This is bad for me, but good for the teenagers out there who are angry at the world. I've never wanted to play a player character who was evil. Even being cruel to imaginary creatures is difficult for me. As someone who enjoys writing creatively, I can only write nasty characters with the personal knowledge that I fully expect to be writing their comeuppance one day. (For an example of my creative fiction, tune in to my Eagles Landing blog.) So you get to choose your own character. That means that your main character is slightly less enjoyable than the npcs (non player characters). NPCs never leave character. And players are inconsistent, and since you get to choose their story, less fascinating than having a traditional yarn. Why is that? Well, I hate making decisions that matter in my own life. The responsibility of having to make them in my videogames isn't a joy, it's one more burden. What that says about me, I don't know.
However, the neatest part of DragonAge is that you can play up your NPCs allegiances. You had a similar capacity in Baldur's Gate, by gaining or losing reputation points. If you had a bad rep, "good" characters would decline to join your party, or would fight other members of the party. DragonAge has expanded on this. You can even sleep with some of your fellow NPCs if you say the right combination of words over the course of the game, and give them the right number of gifts. All of which leads me to another opinion of video gaming. Teenagers and gamers will have the endless hours necessary to unravel all of the game's secrets. Regular Joe's will not. I will probably not buy another video game in a year or two. And in that time, I might finish this game. If I do, I will probably play it again as a different type of character. No way am I going to get through this game six times. Maybe six years from now. But six years from now I'll have kids of my own, and even less time. So it's nice that the game has increased playabilitiy, but it's also nice to have a plethora of online experts providing guidance on how to complete certain quests, and which gifts will make the NPCs take their clothes off sooner. Some of the characters are really enjoyable, like Morrigan, a witch, or apostate, who is pretty hot, and also pretty contrary. Other characters like Alistair provide excellent comic relief and great side quests that really help develop the story.
2) Cliche:
I was waitng for the next big fantasy game to come along. I'm sort of retro in my video gaming. This is because of a general technological lag in equipment, and the fact that I'm fully employed, in grad school, and engaged to a Ph.D. student. This does not leave much time for video game playing.
So you know where I'm coming from, some of my favorite fantasy and fantasy related video games include Heroes of Might and Magic III
So on to DragonAge: Origins. When I finished classes this summer, I wanted some innocuous fun during my time off. I checked list after list for the best RPGs. I wanted something current, but I wanted to stay away from online video games. Why? Without diverging too much: time for videogames, is time for me, and me alone. I am NOT looking for any interraction with the broader populace. I have an active social life, I don't need friends online. This is not to disparage people who do--merely expressing a preference. I was exceedingly disappointed when Square released Final Fantasy 11 as only an online game. That's right--you can't actually even play it without going on line. I was very much afraid that DragonAge would be a game like that. The game does in fact have that capability, but it has an undeniable throughline that is completely playable without the internet. What a relief.
I'd also heard that there were some difficulties with the PC version of the game. Employees of both GameStop and BestBuy who raved about the game, both suggested I buy the console version, and stay away from the PC. Had I an XBox or PS3, I may have done so. But I got a new computer just a year ago. I purposely spent twenty bucks extra for a nice video card, and fifty for extra ram, but my machine is by no means a performance whore. I wouldn't even know how to make a gaming machine. As it is, you'll be glad to know the game plays absolutely fine. The Wiki for DragonAge has reported on some general programming bugs, but they have not made the game in anyway unplayable, unlike my attempt at playing the more recent Heroes of Might and Magic, which required seven different patches to play.
So onto the FFF
Note: I haven't finished the game, I was too excited to wait. And I rarely get to finish videogames, which require a skill and tenacity that simple reading does not.
1) Character:
So holy neato! You don't just play one character in DragonAge Origins. When you start, you get to choose one of six different story lines. The quests are largely universal, but the dialogue changes for each character. You can choose from three races, two genders, and the choice of a Magi, creates a wholly different storyline. I chose the story of a Dwarf Commoner. So, I can almost guarantee that many of the developers who worked on Baldur's Gate, also worked on DragonAge. Much of the informational dialogue is written in the same way, and, the controls and view points are very similar. One neat thing about DragonAge, is that you can zoom in on the character and play it first person, from any perspective. I don't particularly like the claustophobic nature of first person shooters, so I tend to operate at the three quarter level, but when I want to see a detail of the scenery, it's nice to be able to zoom in. As in any video game a la Baldur's Gate, or any role playing game, you get to choose the sort of dialogue you want. You can be a buttface, but you can also play really good characters. This is bad for me, but good for the teenagers out there who are angry at the world. I've never wanted to play a player character who was evil. Even being cruel to imaginary creatures is difficult for me. As someone who enjoys writing creatively, I can only write nasty characters with the personal knowledge that I fully expect to be writing their comeuppance one day. (For an example of my creative fiction, tune in to my Eagles Landing blog.) So you get to choose your own character. That means that your main character is slightly less enjoyable than the npcs (non player characters). NPCs never leave character. And players are inconsistent, and since you get to choose their story, less fascinating than having a traditional yarn. Why is that? Well, I hate making decisions that matter in my own life. The responsibility of having to make them in my videogames isn't a joy, it's one more burden. What that says about me, I don't know.
However, the neatest part of DragonAge is that you can play up your NPCs allegiances. You had a similar capacity in Baldur's Gate, by gaining or losing reputation points. If you had a bad rep, "good" characters would decline to join your party, or would fight other members of the party. DragonAge has expanded on this. You can even sleep with some of your fellow NPCs if you say the right combination of words over the course of the game, and give them the right number of gifts. All of which leads me to another opinion of video gaming. Teenagers and gamers will have the endless hours necessary to unravel all of the game's secrets. Regular Joe's will not. I will probably not buy another video game in a year or two. And in that time, I might finish this game. If I do, I will probably play it again as a different type of character. No way am I going to get through this game six times. Maybe six years from now. But six years from now I'll have kids of my own, and even less time. So it's nice that the game has increased playabilitiy, but it's also nice to have a plethora of online experts providing guidance on how to complete certain quests, and which gifts will make the NPCs take their clothes off sooner. Some of the characters are really enjoyable, like Morrigan, a witch, or apostate, who is pretty hot, and also pretty contrary. Other characters like Alistair provide excellent comic relief and great side quests that really help develop the story.
2) Cliche:
So this game bears a lot of resemblance to the world of Tolkien's Middle Earth. This in no way inhibits the story. It gives the game a certain visual feel. You can almost see Peter Jackson's fine visuals in the opening cinematic sequences of the game. Likewise, the main races are humans, elves and dwarves. That pretty much ends the cliche. Ironically, given the religious nature of Tolkien, there was little reference to classical religion in the Lord of the Rings. DragonAge origins, has an entire religious system that bares striking similarities to Christianity, while also providing excellent critiques of organized religion overall. God is known as The Maker. I like simple names in fantasy, multi syllabic names is often a deflection from real content. They actually use a real group of religious knights, The Knights Templar, to provide a really neat counterpoint to magic. But I'll get to that. One Tolkien cliche avoided is that the villanous Darkspawn, though divided into races that look suspiciously like Orcs, Goblins, Giant Spiders, etc. do not come from different lands or tribes, as they did in Middle Earth. There is a unifed enemy, emerging from the Earth, but also from an alternative demension called The Fade. These creatures are called demons, and are controlled by an arch demon that is said to resemble a dragon. This is a wonderful example of how, a popular cliche (The Dungeons and Dragons cliche), is given new life. Even more fantastic is that as the game progresses, the character can even elect to become a demon, and/or sympathize with demons, who really just want to leave The Fade, and enjoy a more tactile pleasurful existence as a mortal. One memorable scene occurs with a Pleasure Demon, who has seduced a knight Templar. You can kill her, and him, since his mind is utterly controlled, or you can let her and him go, on the premise that he knight has let himself be seduced and that he and the demon really are leading a brief but intimately pleasurable life. Such moral gray tones provide a rich tapestry for the game's story to develop. Rest assured, the demoness will kill her host, but the knight's fantasy is quite humble, a wife and a loving family-things that are forbidden by the holy vows that a knight makes on entry to the society.
3) Scope:
Honestly, I'm still learning about the scope of DragonAge. The World Map is quite large, but so far, only a few areas are playable. These areas have provided many hours of gameplay so far. The game does include a number of brief histories, again, much like Baldur's Gate, called Codexes. These insert a great deal of depth, history, vision and possibility into the story. And again, unlike a paperback, a popular videogame can simply use an expansion pack to enhance and enlarge gameplay and story. But the history of the land is fairly dense, the individual characters have full histories, born in certain cities, living and growing in others. I'd say the game has impressive scope. Also, in the Jordanian strain of fantasy--that scope is hinted at straight from the beginning. This means that as the game grows and expands, the history and story presented will feel more integrated, and less ad hoc, than say, the Seeker series by Terry Goodkind.
4) Magic:
So the system of health and magic is a huge departure from other fantasy games. Each character has a set number of hitpoints and magic points, that grow, as the character grows his stats, again using a D&D cliche, of Strength, Dexterity, Constitution, and several other factors. In combat however, as the fighter uses special abilities, or the mage uses spells, it takes away from stamina, or spell points accordingly. That's standard stuff. What isn't standard is that, once the battle is over, both health and magic regenerate. So rather than carrying hoards of potions, you end up carrying maybe a dozen, and than waiting between battles. This provides some downtime in play, but given the complex operation of the characters, changing armor, equipping weapons, reading codexes, this merely provides another sort of gameplay. The type of spells used is fairly standard, but there is a greater emphasis in delaying and stunning spells. Since the characters do not attack in real time, meaning you can't simply hit the x button twenty times in a row to attack twenty times, delaying other characters attacks provides a real advantage on the field of battle. Likewise, certain spells have cool down periods, ranging from a couple of seconds to a couple of minutes, whereby you'll have to wait before you can recast. Above I alluded to the history of magic in DragonAge. In DragonAge, magic is regulated by the Templars. There appear to be two types of magic, regular, and blood. Blood magic seems to be far more powerful, hence the appeal to evildoers and other teenagers, but it requires ritual sacrifice, hence the prohibition. Mages who are regulated, report to an organization called The Circle. Though the agency has a veneer of self governance, the real power are the Knights Templar, who govern the grounds of the tower and can call the Rite of Annulment if the mages go bad. And there is a very real possibility of that. Another really neat part of the system is that, all mages are vulnerable to being controlled by Darkspawn still trapped in The Fade. One of the main story quests relies on one such character. And you, as player character, get to decide, do you support the Templars unilaterrally and say that the danger posed by mages should be erradicated before people are harmed, or do you believe that some mages are innocents and that all innocents should be protected? And that choice affects the entire storyline! How cool is that?!
5) Theme:
As mentioned above, the overall feel of the game is Tolkienesque. There is a desperation to the Order of The Grey Wardens, your character is one of them, in that the land has on many occasions been affected by The Blight, and on each occasion it has cost more lives to repell. The Blight by the way, is the name for the darkspawn invasion. The Grey Wardens exist to fight The Blight. The theme reeks of Tolkien and Baldur's Gate--but as stated previously--it doesn't detractgameplay, it only serves to enhance it. Those tropes help to color what your eyes already see, and fill in the gaps on the places on the map where nothing seems to exist.
I love this game, and would recommend it to any serious gamer, any "lite" gamer like myself, and also to casual fantasy lovers, looking for some time away from their eReaders and paperbacks.
Wednesday, August 11, 2010
Women Reading on the Subway 1
I'm iritated by the fact that the yuppy women of New York all read the same book each month. So henceforth, I am going to expose them.
Today it was one of these three of these novels. I hate to make this sound sexist. And I don't think it has much to do with women per se, it's just men read less, and so there is much less data to collect. NYC women are particularly easy to peg because subway reading is a "thing" here. It's like any accessory, it matters.
So the first three for the list:
1. The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest - Stieg Larsson
2. The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo - Stieg Larsson
3. The Girl who Played with Fire - Stieg Larsson.
Keep it classy ladies.
Today it was one of these three of these novels. I hate to make this sound sexist. And I don't think it has much to do with women per se, it's just men read less, and so there is much less data to collect. NYC women are particularly easy to peg because subway reading is a "thing" here. It's like any accessory, it matters.
So the first three for the list:
1. The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest - Stieg Larsson
2. The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo - Stieg Larsson
3. The Girl who Played with Fire - Stieg Larsson.
Keep it classy ladies.
Thursday, July 22, 2010
The Books of the South by Glen Cook
So before I go any further I have the following corrections to make. In some of my earliest posts, I referred to Glen Cook as a new fantasy author. He is new to me. His wikipedia page shows that he wrote his first fantasy novel, The Black Company in 1984!! He worked at GM and produced three novels a year as an auto worker! The man was also a soldier, and you can definitely tell. So my apologies to Glen Cook, and my hats off. The Black Company is a truly awesome fantasy series. Cook's writing was miles ahead of his time. The back of my copy even has a shout out by Steven Erikson saying "Glen Cook single-handedly changed the face of fantasy--something a lot of people didn't notice and maybe still don't." I used to think Erikson's originality was unparalleled. Now I can see that he took much of his style from Glen Cook's work.
Anyway, is it too late to do a review of books that were published in the 80s? Absolutely not! They've been rereleased in anthologies and their beautiful covers by Raymond Swanland are sleek and modern. Starting with the cover this book was a great investment. I remember seeing a comic book when I was a kid, that had the picture of a massive warrior, completely covered in blocky slabs of black enameled, spiked steel. The warrior carried a wicked halberd with a blade a foot and a half long. The image was so deeply foreboding and exhilarating that it burned itself inexorably into my mind. Swanland's cover art reminds me of that image--I just had to pick it up. And man am I glad.
The Books of the South takes up where the Black Company ended, in the volume called The White Rose. The anthologist, Tor, made a slightly odd decision in publishing the series in one book. They chose not to bind them in order of publication.
The six original book of the Black Company were published between 1984 to 1990 in this order
1. The Black Company
2. Shadows Linger
3. The White Rose
4. Shadow Games
5. The Silver Spike
6. Dreams of Steel
The new anthology, Books of the South, reverses the order of The Silver Spike and Dreams of Steel. Personally, I don't think this was a great choice. Regardless, the stories are beautiful. I recommend you read the stories in the original order of publication.
The Five Factors
Character
Cook's works are definitely about characters. And, joy of joy, the names are simple, and there aren't too many to remember. The leading man of the series, is a cynical mercenary surgeon called Croaker. Croaker is the story's viewpoint. Unlike some central storytelling characters he is neither ancillary, nor banal. If you're unfamiliar with the series than you should know, the Black Company books are supposedly the Annals, written records, of the mercenary company for which it's named. Cook's characters are the types of people that you want to know more about. Their moniker's are army nicknames. Cook himself served in the military, and their banter and gallows humor is exactly what you might have seen in books or in films. In fact, Cook's dialogue overall is excellent. He doesn't bother with any medieval flourishes, or made up oaths, a major plus in contemporary fantasy fiction. Medieval English, even accurately portrayed, only distances the story from the reader.
Cliche
This is the rare fantasy novel that doesn't use any standard cliches. I don't read much military literature, so I can't honestly say that soldier's banter has become a cliche. Certainly the only other author I've seen use it, is Steven Erikson, who probably borrowed much of his tone from Cook. One of the central characters in this tome and the last, was Lady, the evil empress of the first three Black Company novels. She represents a sort of femme fatale cliche. But there again, femme fatale isn't really a fantasy cliche. To be sure there are dangerous women in fantasy, think Galadriel the elf queen in the Lord of the Rings, who almost takes the ring from Frodo. Femme fatale's have to be sexy, mysterious, and ultimately, fatal or would-be fatal to the protagonists. Cook's lady absolutely is a femme fatal in the first triumvirate of Black Company novels, but not in Books of the South. She progressively becomes more human, more fallible, and less fatal. And Croaker's attraction to her has always been tempered with disgust at the heinous deeds of which she is capable. Cook also skirts another famous fantasy cliche, which I'll call, the Dungeons & Dragons cliche. That means, elves, dwarves, goblins, and dragons. This story doesn't have of those archetypes. It has people and demons. And those demons aren't Buffy the Vampire style either.
Scope:
There is no map to this series. Several ardent fans have created maps for it, but the books themselves do not come with maps. This is both freeing and limiting to the novel. When there's no map, your imagination is free to envision, but if your imagination isn't doing much for you, than it becomes a small and dimly lit world, where peoples and places come out of the gloom unexpectedly and disappear just as unexpectedly. Cook manages to escape this trap. Even though his descriptions are sparse, the names of places remains very consistent with local geography throughout all the novels. Given the break he took between novels, this is all the more impressive. Another contributor to scope is the view point of the main character. The mercenary captain, Croaker, is a bit player in a large world. He's no king, or prince, nor is he destined to fight one, at least not without his crew of murderers. This was more true in the first three series novels, where Croaker isn't even the captain of the outfit, but the medic. As annalist to the company, Croaker indicates constantly to volumes and volumes of the Black Companies adventures. These allusions to a wider world grant scope to the work.
Magic:
So the magic in Books of the South, is really interesting. This is again, a cliche breaking book because absolutely no effort is made to explain how the magic works. You have vast magics, powers dark and dangerous, and magics and creatures of a size that is monumental, and no explanation for them. Normally, this would tick me off. Some things are detailed, but never explained. The most powerful figures in the plot (spoiler alert) need to be hacked to pieces to be killed. And even then, frequently come back together. (Spoiler alert over). I think the only reason this is bearable, is because the novel isn't really about magic at all. It's not really properly a fantasy book. This might be the reason I never saw it until recently, it may well have been sitting elsewhere. The magic becomes a dramatic foil for the complex relationship of the characters, and not an end to itself, as it is in so many fantasy novels. All in all, though unexplained, the magic of Glen Cook's Black Company series is thoroughly enjoyable. Not because it makes sense in any meaningful way, but because it is unpredictable, with a certain degree of wow factor.
Theme:
Which leads us to the final factor. The Black Company is all about theme. Not magic, not fighting, nor fantasy. It's about the brotherhood of soldiers, and a dissemination on the nature of evil. The Black Company is a mercenary band. They don't fight for a cause, they fight for causes. And some of those causes have been black indeed. This moral ambiguity works itself out in the physical description of the universe. For example, there is a general lack of description to the series. The Lady's fortress is described, as are various bars and melee's, but the majority of the prose describes conversations and dramatic conflicts. In the end, theme comes down to sensory descriptions, collections of words, so here is what I felt about The Books of the South: darkness, parchment, blood, sweat, dirt, wicked, the grave, desolation, canteens, long marches.
Without a doubt, I recommend this series heartily.
Anyway, is it too late to do a review of books that were published in the 80s? Absolutely not! They've been rereleased in anthologies and their beautiful covers by Raymond Swanland are sleek and modern. Starting with the cover this book was a great investment. I remember seeing a comic book when I was a kid, that had the picture of a massive warrior, completely covered in blocky slabs of black enameled, spiked steel. The warrior carried a wicked halberd with a blade a foot and a half long. The image was so deeply foreboding and exhilarating that it burned itself inexorably into my mind. Swanland's cover art reminds me of that image--I just had to pick it up. And man am I glad.
The Books of the South takes up where the Black Company ended, in the volume called The White Rose. The anthologist, Tor, made a slightly odd decision in publishing the series in one book. They chose not to bind them in order of publication.
The six original book of the Black Company were published between 1984 to 1990 in this order
1. The Black Company
2. Shadows Linger
3. The White Rose
4. Shadow Games
5. The Silver Spike
6. Dreams of Steel
The new anthology, Books of the South, reverses the order of The Silver Spike and Dreams of Steel. Personally, I don't think this was a great choice. Regardless, the stories are beautiful. I recommend you read the stories in the original order of publication.
The Five Factors
Character
Cook's works are definitely about characters. And, joy of joy, the names are simple, and there aren't too many to remember. The leading man of the series, is a cynical mercenary surgeon called Croaker. Croaker is the story's viewpoint. Unlike some central storytelling characters he is neither ancillary, nor banal. If you're unfamiliar with the series than you should know, the Black Company books are supposedly the Annals, written records, of the mercenary company for which it's named. Cook's characters are the types of people that you want to know more about. Their moniker's are army nicknames. Cook himself served in the military, and their banter and gallows humor is exactly what you might have seen in books or in films. In fact, Cook's dialogue overall is excellent. He doesn't bother with any medieval flourishes, or made up oaths, a major plus in contemporary fantasy fiction. Medieval English, even accurately portrayed, only distances the story from the reader.
Cliche
This is the rare fantasy novel that doesn't use any standard cliches. I don't read much military literature, so I can't honestly say that soldier's banter has become a cliche. Certainly the only other author I've seen use it, is Steven Erikson, who probably borrowed much of his tone from Cook. One of the central characters in this tome and the last, was Lady, the evil empress of the first three Black Company novels. She represents a sort of femme fatale cliche. But there again, femme fatale isn't really a fantasy cliche. To be sure there are dangerous women in fantasy, think Galadriel the elf queen in the Lord of the Rings, who almost takes the ring from Frodo. Femme fatale's have to be sexy, mysterious, and ultimately, fatal or would-be fatal to the protagonists. Cook's lady absolutely is a femme fatal in the first triumvirate of Black Company novels, but not in Books of the South. She progressively becomes more human, more fallible, and less fatal. And Croaker's attraction to her has always been tempered with disgust at the heinous deeds of which she is capable. Cook also skirts another famous fantasy cliche, which I'll call, the Dungeons & Dragons cliche. That means, elves, dwarves, goblins, and dragons. This story doesn't have of those archetypes. It has people and demons. And those demons aren't Buffy the Vampire style either.
Scope:
There is no map to this series. Several ardent fans have created maps for it, but the books themselves do not come with maps. This is both freeing and limiting to the novel. When there's no map, your imagination is free to envision, but if your imagination isn't doing much for you, than it becomes a small and dimly lit world, where peoples and places come out of the gloom unexpectedly and disappear just as unexpectedly. Cook manages to escape this trap. Even though his descriptions are sparse, the names of places remains very consistent with local geography throughout all the novels. Given the break he took between novels, this is all the more impressive. Another contributor to scope is the view point of the main character. The mercenary captain, Croaker, is a bit player in a large world. He's no king, or prince, nor is he destined to fight one, at least not without his crew of murderers. This was more true in the first three series novels, where Croaker isn't even the captain of the outfit, but the medic. As annalist to the company, Croaker indicates constantly to volumes and volumes of the Black Companies adventures. These allusions to a wider world grant scope to the work.
Magic:
So the magic in Books of the South, is really interesting. This is again, a cliche breaking book because absolutely no effort is made to explain how the magic works. You have vast magics, powers dark and dangerous, and magics and creatures of a size that is monumental, and no explanation for them. Normally, this would tick me off. Some things are detailed, but never explained. The most powerful figures in the plot (spoiler alert) need to be hacked to pieces to be killed. And even then, frequently come back together. (Spoiler alert over). I think the only reason this is bearable, is because the novel isn't really about magic at all. It's not really properly a fantasy book. This might be the reason I never saw it until recently, it may well have been sitting elsewhere. The magic becomes a dramatic foil for the complex relationship of the characters, and not an end to itself, as it is in so many fantasy novels. All in all, though unexplained, the magic of Glen Cook's Black Company series is thoroughly enjoyable. Not because it makes sense in any meaningful way, but because it is unpredictable, with a certain degree of wow factor.
Theme:
Which leads us to the final factor. The Black Company is all about theme. Not magic, not fighting, nor fantasy. It's about the brotherhood of soldiers, and a dissemination on the nature of evil. The Black Company is a mercenary band. They don't fight for a cause, they fight for causes. And some of those causes have been black indeed. This moral ambiguity works itself out in the physical description of the universe. For example, there is a general lack of description to the series. The Lady's fortress is described, as are various bars and melee's, but the majority of the prose describes conversations and dramatic conflicts. In the end, theme comes down to sensory descriptions, collections of words, so here is what I felt about The Books of the South: darkness, parchment, blood, sweat, dirt, wicked, the grave, desolation, canteens, long marches.
Without a doubt, I recommend this series heartily.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

