So, this is the second book in the Codex Alera. Part of a six book series. I like that he calls it a Codex, not too many of those—though to be frank unlike a lot of fantasy that creates fake literature to illuminate and foreshadow each chapter, this is noticeably absent from Butcher’s work. I enjoyed this book quite a bit. The plot is complex and full of intrigue, Jim Butcher continues to create a realistic fantasy world. If you are fan of Jim Butcher, check out his fansite, paranetonline!
Character: I think the main reason to read the Codex books is because of his main character, Tavi. He’s just a sunny, tough little guy who never feels sorry for himself and makes things work without all the special gifts that literally every other person in this land has. I just like him, and he’s a joy to read. His Aunt, is a bit of a drag, spoiler alert not really a spoiler alert, we begin to understand a bit more about her personal history. While we are on the topic: a person I respect at work told me her feelings on this book. Namely that a lot of the big reveals are pretty obvious, Tavi’s parentage being the most obvious. While I can see what she's saying, I'd say two things in reprisal: one, this does not detract at all from the excitement of the plot, or overall book enjoyment. Two, what's interesting is just how long these reveals take. By the end of this book you are some 800 pages in, and only one major reveal has taken place. That sort of tension is interesting, and I thought planned. The villains are also quite interesting, all returning from the first book. The sexy Lady Aquitaine, the dangerous and pragmatic spy Fidelious. And of course we get more acquainted with another High Lord, Kalare. Of course my continued sore spot for these novels is the romance and sex between The heroine Amara and the stalwart Bernard—it just doesn’t do anything for me and the intimacy is gratuitous. Both characters and their relationship fall into stereotypes and while I myself am proponent and supporter of cliche, I still find, as per my original review, these displays unpalatable.
Varg, the Canim Ambassador |
Shelob |
Completeness: This for me is where Codex Alera, while great plot driven fantasy does fall down from its ultimate potential as genre busting fantasy. While the plot is complex, and fully realized, as I mentioned earlier, it still lacks the depth and ancient history of Jordan's Wheel of Time, or even Martin's Game of Thrones. These books have histories that go back hundreds and thousands of years. While this is alluded to in the books, as in they are a splinter colony of an ancient Roman legion, the history is really too general to be of interest. It's a pity too because, there is a real opportunity in this book to do so. Tavi is in school, he even has a history exam where he discusses one scholar's old work about furies! Alas, Butcher is many great, great things, but an academic he is not. His scholarly discussion between Tavi and a cantankerous old buffoon is very disappointing. Tavi's best defense of his point of view, is that "many scholars agree". Tavi, this is not how you cite, even in an oral exam! Sigh, but that's my particular bias. Other than that, the realm of enemies and plagues facing Alera are very real, and very complete. This aspect of this very plot driven series is absolutely intact and fascinating.
To sum it all up, I definitely recommend this book, and if you do decide to buy it, click on the opening link and help a guy out!
No comments:
Post a Comment